Skip to main content

Some ideas for improving forums - well Moodle 2.1 forum anyway

As a learner in a research methods unit that is delivered part face-to-face and part online via content and forums, my experience of the Forum in Moodle 2.1 has left me thinking how it could be improved. What would I like to experience or be able to do/know but cannot, given the current design of the tool.

In this short post I would like to list the things I as a learner (to be more specific, a social learner) would like to see. Here is a screenshot of a typical Moodle forum:

Problem No.1: I could stare at this screen for a whole day and it would never change - the system is not telling me if anything in the forum is changing. Why should I have to click refresh? Do any modern systems require me to click refresh to see updates??? Isn't this kind of dynamic/"intelligent" system behavior what students now expect? (refresh? what?)

Problem No.2: I feel quite isolated and alone - I cannot see people coming or going - who is in the forum with me, if anyone? This is like being in a room and seeing messages suddenly appear on a whiteboard - but not having any hint at all that someone is in the room with me - no wonder people take a while to get used to FORUMS!

Do current online forum really support engagement? Is this social construction of knowledge at it's best? I think it could be improved.

From a student perspective "trying" to engage with others online via a forum I would like to see the following improvements:
  • The unread and replies count should increase dynamically without my intervention. I want to see what others are doing real time. While I am multitasking with my weekly forum window open I want the system to tell me when something changes. If all I want is the forum digest I wouldn't even have this forum open unless I wanted to contribute. I have this forum open because I want to engage with my peers and teachers, and to know when others want to engage with me or even others in the group.
  • I am seeking engagement and social presence - I want to see who else is active in the forum when I am rather than others being invisible, the only evidence of their interaction with the rest of us being a fully constructed post. I would like the forum to actively tell me when someone is reading a post - when someone is writing a post - I want to see activity. I want to know when people are in the forum in real time so that I can also choose to interact with them synchronously by clicking on their name. I could do this because Moodle has shown me they are present in the learning space (not - moodle in general - the learning space in this context is the forum - we might call it "contextualized presence") at the same time I am. Moodle should help learners connect in these contextualized spaces as well as the "oh your logged in to" macro kind of contexts.

In my view forums as a communications medium and an information system need to move past the Asynchronous and into the mixed up world of both Asynchronous and Synchronous - these modes don't have to be mutually exclusive. In my view we need to do this in-order to better support connectivist and social constructivist approaches and learning styles and bring our beloved forums into the 21st century.


Popular posts from this blog

What does 2021 hold for student #learningexperience at my university

"Handwriting Text E-Learning Loading. Concept meaning Forecasting the future event"   by  is licensed under  CC BY 2.0 This year we have a unique opportunity to capitalise on what was 2020 and all the impacts it had on learning and teaching.  Staff ICT literacy levels and confidence increased because they had to use digital tools for teaching, there was no choice. This situation was complicated, academics of all levels of ICT literacy had to adapt. Some staff had zero experience with digital tools and were using online tools for the first time, while others are always pushing boundaries and looking for alternative tools available from central support areas. As with staff, some students have very low ICT literacy, while others blaze ahead of the curve, using the tools like pros and needing much instruction. They just work it out. Shifting this cohort of students and staff to fully online was a massive undertaking and a huge shock for everyone.  Going into 2020

University of Canberra Library adds #VR Headsets to the catalogue - on the road to immersive learning resources in #Education

In September 2018 the UC Library added VR headsets to the catalogue, available in the short loan section. Students can loan the headsets for up to 3 hours. Support for using the headsets will be limited to basic guidance, and beyond this it will be up to students to have their apps and content ready, just needing the headset to get going. Supporting this technology is difficult given the number of different phones, OS versions and apps out there giving rise to any app recommendations working on one phone and not another. For this reason support will be limited, however as our in-house knowledge grows more advice will be able to be given. A small number of headsets to start with represents a low risk investment that also allows staff to up skill in VR technology. Demo sessions and training given to Library staff has been fun and a valuable sharing activity as everyone is at different stages of familiarity. Now that a number of staff in the library have been up skilled we can begin t

Make your #onlinelearning experience more personal with a #lightboard

In August 2019 the DVCA at UC wanted to invest in some light boards as he had seen the educational benefits at the previous university he worked for. I was tasked with putting in a comprehensive bid to an annual equipment fund and, if successful, follow the process through to implementation working with AV Services, and Library Services. As of March 2020 the Library houses UC's first ever Lighboard, and academic staff are putting it to good use. The Lightboard is a glass panel filled with light which stands between the teacher and the audience/camera. The teacher faces the camera (viewers) and writes on the glass using liquid chalk (for best results), the results glow on the glass, and a camera is used to record the session. The camera we use flips the image horizontally so the writing appears in the correct orientation without having to flip it in a post production process. The videos capture the face and hand movements/gestures of the teacher, as well as the hand written conten